There are countless auto repair shops in New York City. The best advice is to just shop around and if possible, use a repair shop that has been recommended to you. If you need repairs due to an accident, your insurance company will pay for the work. However, before you have the repairs done, talk to your insurance company. Often, you will need to pay for the repairs and then be reimbursed. The table lists some of the highest rated auto-repair shops in New York according to customer rating.